Wikipedia:Arbitration/Policy/Proposals/Deferring matters
 | This page is currently inactive and is retained for historical reference. Either the page is no longer relevant or consensus on its purpose has become unclear. To revive discussion, seek broader input via a forum such as the village pump. |
Please direct preliminary discussion to the talk page.
Summary of proposal[edit]
If the Arbitration Committee is going to only preside over a certain area, it must have the ability to defer matters appropriately elsewhere. Although not really necessary to add anything to this effect, just a nice thing to include. --AllyUnion (talk) 08:17, 15 Mar 2005 (UTC)
Proposed changes[edit]
Jurisdiction[edit]
Change line X
- 7. The Committee has jurisdiction over the official mailing list "WikiEN-l" and the English Wikipedia only; its jurisdiction does not cover the IRC channels, private email exchanges, nor any other arena of conflict or dispute.
...to either:
- 7. The Committee may consider contributions made to the official mailing list "WikiEN-l" and the English Wikipedia only; it may not consider disuccsions on the IRC channels, private email exchanges, nor any other arena of conflict or dispute. The Committee shall defer all matters regarding all other Wikimedia Foundation projects that is not in its scope to the appropriate equivalent Arbritration Committee(s).
..or:
- 7. The Committee may consider contributions made to the official mailing list "WikiEN-l" and the English Wikipedia only; it may not consider discussions on the IRC channels, private email exchanges, nor any other arena of conflict or dispute. The Committee shall defer all matters not in its scope to an appropriate authority or authorities.
..or:
- 7. The Committee may consider contributions made to the official mailing list "WikiEN-l" and the English Wikipedia only; it may not consider discussions on the IRC channels, private email exchanges, nor any other arena of conflict or dispute. The Committee shall defer all matters regarding all other Wikimedia Foundation projects that is not in its scope to the appropriate authority or authorities in place on that project.
Preliminary poll (none yet)[edit]
Do not open this vote until at least two weeks of discussion have occurred.
Support[edit]
Oppose[edit]
Other[edit]
Final vote (none yet)[edit]
Do not open this vote until the preliminary poll has passed with at least ~70% support.